Cake Testimonials

At Cake Fiction we are proud of our growing reputation as creators of beautiful and delicious specialty cakes. Whether we are working on the centerpiece for a wedding, a bridal shower, baby shower, anniversary or just another birthday, our aim is to achieve pastry perfection.

We are proud to have been recognized for consecutive years as a leading wedding cake vendor by both Wedding Wire and The Knot magazine as a result of the independent reviews our brides have posted about our business.

Wedding Wire Couples Choice Award 2020The Knot Best of Weddings Hall of Fame

Please leave Us a Review

We’ve found that customer reviews are critical to convince new people to try our amazing cakes! We are in debt to each one of you that chooses us to create a cake for your event, and then takes the time to provide feedback in a review that will help others make that same choice!

Visit your preferred site to leave a review or comment, we are especially hoping for more reviews on Google+ so if you have a gmail account then do click that button:

Review Us On:

If time is running short just leave us a Comment on our Facebook Page or +1 us on Google!

What Customers Say About Us

The following testimonials were provided spontaneously by our customers, and we hope their words will encourage you to trust us with your next cake order:

P.S. become a fan on Facebook or follow my blog to stay inspired for your event

Birch Wood Theme Wedding Cake – “Thank you again for the WONDERFUL cake!  People have been raving about it!  It was beautiful and delicious! This is the link to our photographer’s early photos, which includes a nice shot of the cake, but I’ll forward on any other photos of the cake as well.” AP

Naked Cake with Succulents and Tea Rose Sugar Flowers – “Words can’t express how much I loved the cake at our Rat’s Restaurant wedding. It was more beautiful than I ever envisioned. The dogs were the perfect touch. AND the cake was delicious!! Thanks again.” CH

Naked Wedding Cake with fresh summer fruit, also Croquembouche and Macarons – “Let me just thank you for the cake and the pastries. They were absolutely delicious! Both of the croquembouches ended up being packed up for my family the night of the wedding at The Rockleigh, but they were so good that us and our parents and siblings managed to finish them both the morning after. Passion fruit and dulce de leche were to die for. We didn’t end up doing the traditional saving of the top layer, but we’re hoping to order a smaller version of the cake and the pastries for our anniversary just to relive all of the deliciousness:)” YB

Ivory Drape Wedding Cake with Bouquet of Hydrangeas – “We loved the cake, it was exactly what I had envisioned and was so good to eat too :) I’ll recommend you to all of my friends for sure! Thanks again for being part of our special day.” MA

Thomas the Tank Engine Birthday Cake – “Paula the Thomas cake was awesome!!!! You did incredible job, everyone loved it! I will send you some pics of it on the table in case you want to use for website; I set it up with train tracks running around it!” CS

…and the Maid of Honor wrote “I just wanted to that you so very much for being a special part of my sister’s wedding.  The cake was stunning, simple yet elegant, exactly what she wanted.  Then the best part was the inside.  It was rich and moist!  Red velvet is our favorite.  Thank you again and we really appreciate how wonderful you were to work with! Best of luck with your fantastic cakes!” ME

Purple Orchids Wedding Cake with Piped Scrolls - “Paula and her husband were a pleasure to work with. She answered emails promptly and thoroughly. Our wedding cake & grooms cake came out beautifully!!!” NG posted on The Knot

Summertime Cake with Flip Flops and Seashells – “Hi Paula, I just wanted to let you know how much we all loved the cake. It was beautiful and delicious! Everyone commented on how amazing the cake was and how great the detail was. The bride loved the cake and especially loved the chocolate with the mint filling that was my favorite too!!! But i just wanted to thank you for the hard work and time you put into the cake. It was perfect and we couldn’t be any happier with it! As soon as she has a baby I will be contacting you for a Baby Shower cake! Thanks sooooo much!”  JL

Blue and White Jungle Animals Cake – “Thank you for the beautiful cake you created for my son’s 1st birthday party this past Saturday. Not only was it stunning, it was absolutely delicious. It was the hit of the party, and not ONE guest left without mentioning how amazing the cake looked and tasted. I am still getting compliments on it days later. Thank you so much for the time and effort you put into this cake. I am holding on to your card for future events for myself and friends of mine. Thank you for making our son’s birthday so picture perfect.” AL

Bongo Drums and Maracas Cake – “I am fascinated by your cake designs.  I attended a party on August 8 and the party host had the bongo drums and maracas cake.  I personally thought it was unique and tasted good.  I just noticed the ipod; love it.” IB

Building Block Cake for Baby Shower – “I  wanted to thank you for the beautiful cake. Everyone loved it and it was delicious.” RH

Cascading Daisies Communion Cake -  “The cake was brilliant and the perfect size, with enough left over for A to continue eating for a couple of days!”  WF

Domino Mini-cakes - “Thank for making my little cakes. They are darling!” SG

Fall Wedding Cake with Dahlias and Chrysanthemums – “I just wanted to tell you how much we all loved the wedding cake!  It was delicious and looked absolutely beautiful!
We will send you the pictures of the cake when we get them.
Thank you again.  M was so happy with the cake!!” AC

iPod Groom’s Cake – “He loved the cake and everyone was amazed!!! Can’t wait for the wedding!! Thank you Cake Fiction!!!!”

Ivory Wedding Cake with Calla Lillies – “All was perfect!!!  And the cakes were absolutely delicious.” LH

Kenworth Truck Cake – “Hi Paula just wanted to thank you and Simon for everything, my brother loved it and everyone else to they were amazed I also gave your website to a few people again thanks and take care.” VF

Louboutin Shoe Cake – “Thank you so much for your amazing work! It was beyond my expectations and everyone absolutely loved the cake! The look on my sisters face when they brought out the cake was priceless !! She loved it so much, she didn’t even want to cut it! Also, the combination of flavors were delicious and everyone was raving about it, even the onlookers sitting near us couldn’t stop looking!” JO

Musical Notes – “Thank you for making such a beautiful cake for the piano recital, everyone just loved it. I think it was the hit of the recital. Thank you again”.  VT

Pink and Purple Crown Cake – “Hi Paula and Simon – Thank you for making my daughter’s day! You guys are incredible!  On such short notice, you were able to articulate and create the most phenomenally yummy cake!  Many thanks! It was a HIT at the party.” YG

Roses and Pearls 40th Birthday Cake – “Thank you for the cake, it was beautiful and everybody enjoyed it.” JR-B

Seton Hall Blue Wedding Mini-Cakes – “First of all, I want to thank you for all your hard work in making my mini cakes. I know you probably lost alot of sleep slaving away but the final product was so amazing. It was the perfect focal point of the reception and it really added “pop” to the room. You captured the royal blue so perfectly. I continue to get compliments of how beautiful they were and most of all, how DELICIOUS they were! We saved our cake and put it in the freezer but I don’t think I can wait a whole year to eat it! Thank you thank you!” FE


Tractor and Farmyard Animals Cake with Red Tractor Cookies – “I just wanted to tell you that the cake was absolutely wonderful. It was both beautiful and totally delicious.  In short it surpassed our expectations in every way.  And the cookies were a huge hit, too. Thanks for helping make our son’s birthday extra special.” DG

Wedding Dress Cookie Favors for Baby Shower  – “Just wanted to thank you on another beautiful creation with the cookies…. They were the hit of the party!” SG

Red Paisley Wedding Cake  – “The cake was FANTASTIC! It was so beautiful. And it tasted wonderful of course! We couldn’t be happier with how it turned out.
Your work is so amazing. When we came to your store, we already knew this right away. But the cake you did for us is the most beautiful dessert either of us has ever seen. We can’t thank you enough for making the cake so special.” SP and TL

Read all of our Wedding Cake Reviews at